Hull City Supporters at the 2014 FA Cup Final against Arsenal

“One of the most dramatic FA Cup semi-finals ever” – that was the description used by BBC commentator Guy Mowbray as Watford celebrated their miraculous 3-2 comeback over Wolves at Wembley this weekend. The win put the Hornets through to the final – an opportunity that’s usually relished by some, apathetic to others. Fans have been questioning the importance and relevance of the FA Cup for a few years now, but the oldest national cup competition in the world still holds some sentimental value in my eyes, it just depends who you support…

For Watford, you could see the jubilation amongst the 33,000 that made the short trip south for the semi-final, having seen their team pull out a stunning second-half performance involving a last minute spot-kick to send them through. Conversely, you could see the disappointment and sorrow amongst those in orange at the southern end of the ground after letting a two goal lead drop. The similarities however? Both teams cared. They both cared badly.

Compare this to the other semi-final where Manchester City ran out 1-0 winners over Brighton thanks to a diving header from Gabriel Jesus in the opening exchanges. Yes they were

The infamous FA Cup trophy

happy when they scored. Yes they were happy at the full-time whistle. However, something just doesn’t sit right with me. Brighton gave the league-leaders a good run for their money in front of the 35,000 travelling seagull fans. It was also their first appearance at the new Wembley in the usual context (they played Tottenham there when it was used as their temporary home ground). They embraced the occasion.

For City though, this was routine. It was the fourth time The Citizens had visited the national stadium just this season alone, competing for the 2018 Community Shield, the Tottenham league fixture and the Carabao Cup final. Now they’re heading back for a fifth time. To say the novelty has worn off would be putting it lightly – City failed to sell out their allocation for the semi-final and sent tickets back prior to the game. What I’m trying to get at here is that the FA Cup is not dead, it just really is contextual to the team you support.

Aaron Flanagan, a Sports Writer at the Mirror, thinks this is the case: “It really depends on the team you support but I love it nonetheless. Any team can play absolutely anyone and the financial influence it has on lower league teams is huge. The occasion it creates is absolutely magic – something you can’t get in any other competition.”

“However I can see how it doesn’t necessarily benefit the top teams from a financial perspective. It depends who you are a fan of and what you priortise at that club. Do you look at the cup in awe of going on a good run or is it good to go on a run because it makes you more money? It really is dependent on the outlook of the club,” added Flanagan.

As a Portsmouth fan myself, the FA Cup has a very special place in our hearts – we’ve won the competition twice and as a club currently competing in the third tier of English football (sadly), the FA Cup is still something we take very seriously. There is also nothing better than seeing a lower league club going on a cup run, giving the players and fans an opportunity they have never experienced before, let alone if they knock someone big out.

It was a momentous occasion for those County fans, who had seen their club go from doom and gloom to creating one of the most emphatic cup stories ever.

This year’s dark horses were Newport, currently in League Two, who somehow managed to make it to the fifth round. For a club who went through financial turmoil and had to start-up new, working their way back through the leagues to make it back professional, this was the highlight of their most recent history. Many had never seen anything like it, being over 70 years since the club had made it to the same round. It was a momentous occasion for those County fans, who had seen their club go from doom and gloom to creating one of the most emphatic cup stories ever.

Even at the summit of English football though, the competition doesn’t necessarily lack relevancy. Wolves and Watford were battling it out to be labelled the best team outside the top six the other day – the FA Cup acting yet again as a platform for both clubs to make a successful season even more successful. For the likes of Man City and Liverpool, to generalise, they have other priorities. A Premier League or Champions League trophy is the overall goal, with an FA Cup win probably not enough to consider the season a good one for clubs of that stature. All in all, don’t sleep on the FA Cup, I promise you the magic is still there…